Ep. 180 – Online Mortgage Calculators Are GARBAGE – Here’s Why 

 April 26, 2023

How to Buy a Home Podcast

Ep. 180 – Online Mortgage Calculators Are GARBAGE – Here’s Why

Shownotes:

There are TONS of online mortgage calculators where you can type in your numbers and find out what mortgage you can afford. Sounds cool, right? Well, David checked them all out and the bottom line is that they are not accurate. In this episode, he gives you some truth bombs about the one-size-fits-all approach to buying a home. If you want a hint, think Chutes and Ladders. Sound familiar?

Here are some takeaways from today’s conversation:

  • Why mortgage calculators are wrong
  • Target shopping vs. flea market shopping
  • Preparing to buy no matter your situation
  • PERSONAL finances

Episode Highlights:

[1:30] Don’t Listen To Everything on the Internet

In the age of instant answers online, it can be super tempting to try and calculate what mortgage you’ll be approved for through an online calculator. But, wait! These mortgage calculators really only have 4 or 5 data entry points in order to calculate that number, which is totally NOT going to give you an accurate reading. These calculators don’t factor in taxes, 1099s, or marital status, or so many other things that could make all the difference, meaning that your answer could be off by $100,000 (over or under)! If you base your plan on a calculator number, it could take you down a chute and farther away from your goal.

[10:20] The Flea Market Approach

Some people might think that getting a loan is like going to Target where everyone spends $100 and gets the same end result. You’re all buying and it’s all equal and everyone has a loan of up to $400,000 buying the same goods. WRONG. Buying a home is like buying at a flea market. It’s not cut and dry, everyone is a different buyer buying from different sellers. It could be really great or it could be really sketchy – it totally depends on the buyer and the seller.

Buying a home is like going to the flea market. Your success depends on a wide variety of factors.
Buying a home is like going to the flea market. Your success depends on a wide variety of factors.

[17:25] Your Relative Happily Ever After

Forget the 5 data entry points on your loan calculator: it’s important to talk to a professional because there is no one-size-fits-all approach to buying a home. And maybe you’re not ready to buy a home right now – that’s okay! Perhaps you’re living the nomadic lifestyle or it just doesn’t make sense to purchase a home because of your job. That’s totally fine. But talking to a professional allows you to prepare for whatever the future holds.

About the author

David Sidoni is the host of the How to Buy a Home Podcast and a nationally recognized real estate educator for first-time buyers. With over 4,100 real-life success stories, David has spent more than a decade helping renters break the cycle and become confident, prepared homeowners. His honest, myth-busting advice has made him one of the most trusted voices in the homebuying space.

You Might Also Be Interested In:

Home Prices, Mortgage Rates & Confusion – May 2025 Housing Market Update for First-Time Homebuyers
Construction Tariffs and Housing Impact 2025: What First-Time Buyers Should Know
Battling Mold, Bad Advice, and Moving Mayhem in Pittsburgh, PA – Ep. 338
Tips for Buying a Home in a High-Cost Area – Long Island, NY – Ep. 321